You asked

Pentax hd da 20 40mm f 2 8 4 ed limited dc wr vs tamron 17 50mm f 2 8?

I don't have a page for the Tamron 17-50mm f/2.8, so I can't compare the two fairly from here. I can tell you about the Pentax, though. The Pentax HD DA 20-40mm f/2.8-4 ED Limited DC WR is an APS-C zoom for Pentax K bodies. It has a small metal barrel and is weather-resistant. On APS-C it frames roughly like 30-60mm on full frame. It isn't stabilised, and its aperture narrows from f/2.8 to f/4 as you zoom in, so it's darker at the long end than a constant f/2.8 zoom. It suits Pentax shooters who want something compact and well built.

If you're choosing a first standard zoom, the Lenses page sets out what to look for, and Your first camera explains how to split the budget.

Written by Claude from this site's pages.

From these pages